The Loss of Palmyra and the Bamiyan Buddhas
Keywords:
Palmyra, Bamiyan Buddhas, Western Cultural Imperialism, Memory in Digital Space, Politics of ReconstructionAbstract
This essay analyses how the destruction of the Bamiyan Buddhas is relevant to an understanding of the asymmetrical responses of the West to the destruction of two cultural heritage sites in Asia: the Bamiyan Buddhas in Afghanistan, and Palmyra, the World Heritage Site in Syria. The singular focus on Palmyra, by the Western coalitions/countries has resulted in a transformation of memory about Palmyra in the aftermath of the ISIS attacks on Palmyra. Therefore, I argue that the destruction of the Bamiyan Buddhas does not receive as much attention as what has happened with Palmyra. This is primarily because the Bamiyan Buddhas have been inherently perceived as belonging to the Eastern realm or culture. When the West claimed custodianship of Palmyra, there was also an intense effort to reconstruct the spatial geography and architectural forms of Palmyra. It became a means of recovering place rather than the memory of the ancient and local culture of Palmyra. This section further discusses why the transformation of Palmyra in the hands of the West has a global impact. It also reassesses the prominence of Palmyra as a center of civilizational memory as reimagined by the West and how Palmyra became a patrimony of the West in the process. I conclude with the discussion that, these efforts to reclaim Palmyra by the West as a patrimony of the West must be juxtaposed against the reality that Palmyra’s antiquities have always remained present in the lives of Syrians and people living in the region. Therefore, the real Palmyra where it once stood majestically is lost somewhere in translation and transference.
References
Bevan, Robert. The Destruction of Memory: Architecture at War. Reaktion Books Ltd, 2016.
Campion, Kristy. “Blast through the Past Terrorist Attacks on Art and Antiquities as a Reconquest of the Modern Jihadi Identity.” Perspectives on Terrorism vol. 11, no. 1 2017, p. 34.
Cascone, Sarah. “Nearly Destroyed by ISIS, the Ancient City of Palmyra Will Reopen in 2019 After Extensive Renovations.” Artnet News, 27 Aug. 2018, news.artnet.com/ art-world/syria-isis-palmyra-restoration-1338257. Accessed 11 May 2019.
Gladstone, Rick, and Hwaida Saad. “ISIS Fighters Laid Mines Around Palmyra’s Ancient Ruins Before Retreating, Syrians Say.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 30 Mar. 2016, www.nytimes.com/2016/03/30/world/middleeast/isis-fighters-laid- mines-around-palmyras-ancient-ruins-before-retreating-syrians-say.html. Accessed 5 May 2018.
“Google lets destroyed Lion of Mosul roar again.” BBC, 2 Jul. 2019, https://www.bbc.com/ news/technology-48839818. Accessed 18 Oct. 2019.
Huyssen, Andreas. Present Pasts Urban Palimpsests and the Politics of Memory. Stanford Univ. Press, 2009.
John, Tara. “Russian Orchestra Plays In Syrian Ruins of Palmyra.” Time, Time, 6 May 2016, time.com/4320723/russia-orchestra-concert-syria-palmyra/. Accessed 7 Jul. 2018.
Katz, Brigit. “Ancient City of Palmyra, Gravely Damaged by ISIS, May Reopen Next Year.” Smithsonian.com, Smithsonian Institution, 29 Aug. 2018, www.smithsonianmag. com/smart-news/ancient-city-palmyra-gravely-damaged-isis-may-reopen-next- year-1-180970160/. Accessed 18 Sep. 2019.
Mudie, Ella. “ Palmyra and the Radical Other : on the Politics of Monument Destruction in Syria.” Otherness: Essays and Studies, vol. 6, no. 2, Dec. 2018, pp. 139–160., doi:https:// www.otherness.dk/fileadmin/www.othernessandthearts.org/Publications/ Journal_Otherness/Otherness_Essays_and_Studies_6/2_-_Ella_Mudie_-Palmyra_ and_the_Radical_Other.pdf.
Norland, Rod. “2 Giant Buddhas Survived 1,500 years. Fragments, Graffiti and a Hologram Remains.” The New York Times, 18 Jun. 2019, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/18/ world/asia/afghanistan-bamiyan- buddhas.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share. Accessed 22 Aug. 2019.
“Once Destroyed by the Taliban, the Buddha Statues Live Again.” BBC News, BBC, 17 Apr. 2019, www.bbc.com/news/av/world-asia-47954950/once-destroyed-by-the-taliban- the-buddha-statues-live-again. Accessed 23 Jun. 2019.
Press, Michael. “The Getty’s Online Palmyra Exhibition Falls into Orientalist Traps.” Hyperallergic, 1 Mar. 2017, hyperallergic.com/360675/the-gettys-online- palmyra-exhibition-falls-into-orientalist-traps/. Accessed 18 Feb. 2018.
Raja, Rubina, and Annette Højen Sørensen. Harald Ingholt & Palmyra. Museum of Ancient Art at Aarhus University, 2015.
Richardson, Nigel. “The Arch of Triumph of Palmyra Is Recreated in London - 1,800 Years after It Was Built.” The Telegraph, Telegraph Media Group, 19 Apr. 2016, www. telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/04/08/why-the-arch-of-triumph-of-palmyra-is-being- recreated-in-london/. Accessed 22 Aug. 2019.
Robinson, Douglas. Exorcising Translation: towards an Intercivilizational Turn. Bloomsbury Academic, 2017.
Romey M, Kristin. “Cultural Terrorism.” Archaeology vol. 54, no. 3 May/Jun. 2001.
Rowland D, Ingrid. “Breakfast in the Ruins.” The New York Review of Books, 17 Sep. 2016, www.nybooks.com/daily/2016/09/17/breakfast-in-the-ruins- palmyraphotographs/. Accessed 18 Dec. 2017.
Serbenco, Par Eduard. “The Protection of Cultural Property and Post-conflict Kosovo.” Revue Québécoise de Droit International vol. 18, no. 2 2005, pp. 91-126.
Terpak, Frances, and Peter Louis Bonfitto. “Palmyra in the Modern Era.” The Legacy of Ancient Palmyra (Getty Research Institute), www.getty.edu/research/exhibitions_events/ exhibitions/palmyra/palmyra_today.html. Accessed 11 May 2016.
Tresilian, David. ““Cultural Catastrophe” Hits Iraq.” Al-Ahram Weekly, 24-30 Apr. 2003, https://www.globalpolicy.org/component/content/article/167/35481.html. Accessed 29 May 2017.